Grey Cup For Hockey?

I’ve written on this site before, years ago, about my long family history with Canadian Football and the Grey Cup. (I touched on this subject too.) Even more than hockey and baseball, I watch a lot less football (CFL or NFL) than I used to. But the Toronto Argonauts were my first favourite team, and I’ve been watching the Grey Cup since 1971. So, of course I watched on Sunday!

Without the Argos, I don’t have much of a rooting interest, but I saw plenty of Edmonton versus Montreal Grey Cup games in my early football fandom, and this one was very entertaining. Congratulations to the Elks (who, for those who don’t know, is the more politically correct name the former Eskimos adopted in 2022).

Congratulations to the 2026 Grey Cup champion Edmonton Elks. And that’s the original Grey Cup base on the right.

Not surprisingly, part of what I like about Canadian football is the long history of it. The Argos date back to 1873 and the teams in Ottawa, Hamilton and Montreal have roots to about the same time. Though the Grey Cup wasn’t donated until 1909, there has been a Canadian football (rugby) championship since 1884.

The Toronto Star, Janaury 14, 1909 on the left, and the Ottawa Journal from the following day.

Lord Albert Henry George Grey, the 4th Earl Grey, and Canada’s Governor-General from 1904 to 1911, was a great sportsman – as many of his predecessors had been. By 1908, he had already donated namesake trophies for the Dominion trapshooting championship and for horse racing. A couple of years earlier, in the fall of 1906, the two top hockey leagues in Canada – the newly organized Eastern Canada Amateur Hockey Association and the Manitoba Hockey League – voted to allow professional athletes to play alongside amateurs. This was more than just a decision of whether to pay players or not, it was a true philosophical divide.

The Calgary Albertan, February 12, 1909 and The Globe from Toronto on February 17.

Many sportsmen, and many sports, in Canada were staunchly amateur and even if hockey was now allowing pros and amateurs to mix, other sports (notably football and rowing) were dead set against it. Many hockey players, wishing to maintain their amateur status for other sports, didn’t want to become professionalized … which they could be by simply agreeing to play against professionals even if they weren’t being paid themselves. So when the trustees in charge of the Stanley Cup agreed to allow professional players and teams to compete for their trophy in 1906–07, a need arose for a national hockey championship trophy for amateur players. In January of 1909, it seems that two prominent men in Canada were wishing to promote amateur hockey by donating a new championship trophy.

Many early hockey stars played rugby/football too. That’s Art Ross with the arrow above him and neighbourhood friend Frank Patrick, who won the Canadian intermediate rugby championship for the Montreal suburb of Westmount in 1903.

Prior to the 1908–09 season, the only amateur teams in the Eastern Canada Amateur Hockey Association, the Montreal Victorias and the Montreal Amateur Athletic Association, had broken away to join teams from Ottawa and Toronto to form the new Interprovincial (Amateur) Hockey Union. (The ECAHA dropped the first A and became the Eastern Canada Hockey Association.) On January 14, 1909, The Toronto Daily Star, followed the next day by The Evening Journal in Ottawa, reported that Sir H. Montagu Allan (Hugh Andrew Montagu Allan), who had succeeded his grandfather and father in running the Allan Steamship Line and who was prominent in many Montreal business, philanthropic and sports organizations, was going to donate a championship trophy for the new Interprovincial league. Earl Grey, it was said, was going to donate a trophy for the amateur hockey championship of the entire country. But the story changed the following month.

The donation of the Allan Cup as reported in the Montreal Star on February 20, 1909.

On February 12, 1909, The Morning Albertan in Calgary (and then numerous other newspapers all across Canada in the days that followed) reported that Grey was talking to J.A. McCullough of Calgary about a hockey trophy to be competed for by amateur teams in the western provinces of Manitoba, Saskatchewan and Alberta. Perhaps by that time, the thinking was that Allan’s trophy would be open to teams in Eastern Canada beyond the Interprovincial Hockey Union and that a similar trophy for the West would be appreciated. But on February 20, 1909, as reported in both The Montreal Daily Star and The Gazette of that city, Allan’s plan was to donate his trophy of the Interprovincial Hockey Union with the expectation that other teams would be able to challenge for it, thereby “stimulating the interest in amateur hockey throughout Canada.”

Kingston’s British Whig from March 19, 1909 and The Daily Standard on March 26.

Though only teams from Ontario and Quebec would play for the Allan Cup in 1909 and 1910, by 1911 the Winnipeg Victorias had challenged for it, and though they won it by default that year they would defeat all comers from the East and further West in 1912. Perhaps Earl Grey saw the writing on the wall and thought that since hockey would have its national amateur championship trophy he should switch sports. From what I’ve been able to find, it seems that only Kingston newspapers had the story at first, but The Daily British Whig on March 19, 1909 and The Daily Standard on March 26 both reported that Grey was going to give a “valuable” and “magnificent” silver cup/trophy to rugby/football.

From the Ottawa Citizen on June 1, 1909.

By June 1, 1909 – as reported in newspaper all across the country – Early Grey had decided to donate a trophy for the rugby football championship of Canada. But according to the web site of the Canadian Football Hall of Fame and Museum, “Having decided to offer the trophy, the Governor General promptly forgot about his promise and the cup was not ready to present to the first senior Dominion Champions, the University of Toronto, in December 1909. Two weeks prior to the championship game, a series of letters was exchanged and a hurried order placed with the silversmiths to produce a sterling silver cup, on a wooden base, total cost: $48.00. Three months later, in March 1910, the Grey Cup was presented to the University of Toronto.” Once the Grey Cup finally arrived in Toronto it went on display at a prominent local jewelers.

Toronto Star, March 29, 1910 and May 3, 1910 … and “borrowed” from Facebook.

8 thoughts on “Grey Cup For Hockey?”

  1. Not a big football fan. When I was in high school many girls went to the games to cheer the team from Jarvis CI. Then there was a wild battle with Jarvis and another school, and after that, no non-playing students could attend the games. I missed that one, but heard there were police, ambulances and a fire truck who had to drive into the field. What astounds me now, and looking at the old photos in the posting, is the lack of protective gear the players had. Today, it is amazing how the players can possibly get hurt with the helmets, padding everywhere.
    I have to admit, I prefer a good soccer game to a football game. It is fun to read the history of the Grey Cup, etc. Amazing research, Eric!! Keep up the great work!

  2. Eric’s brilliance touched a lot of my memories. As a NY correspondent for the Toronto Tar (1960s for a decade) I got a kick outd of the Star photo. likely the King Street building which I often visited until the move to the waterfront. As a teenaged Leafs fan, I subscribed to the Globe and Mail and always read the CFL stories and admired Joe Krol The Allan Cup was also a big deal for me, especially in the late 1940s into the 1950s. My affection for the Edmonton Eskimos immediately end with the absurd name change! Period!!

  3. That was a great read, Eric!
    This Earl Grey fella sounds pretty flaky, but I guess he managed to make his name live on.

  4. Wonderful article! And, yup, I was actually searching the photo & spotted Gramp before I read the caption! Yes, the red arrow helped, but knowing how much he loved rugby I thought it worth a look. Thank you, as always, for always reminding me what an incredible, versatile, all-around athlete he was!

  5. Great history Eric. I remember some great athletes who played hockey and football in school but only hockey when they left school. I remember some great ones who could easily have continued playing at a higher level but found it more important to go to work in in the paper mill.

  6. Fascinating history of the CUP! I’d no idea! And to think it only cost $48.~ Too funny…
    Also I only knew of Earl Grey because of the tea I drink… he apparently had many interests.
    I missed the Grey Cup. I thought it was THIS coming Sunday…*sighs* Guess I’ll be waiting a year for the next one.
    I will admit I’m more into NFL than CFL but Football is FOOTBALL ya know???
    Thans for a great post Eric!
    ((hugs)) Sherri-Ellen

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *