I’ve never really been one of those Jewish sports fans who cares a whole lot if a player is Jewish. But I do love trying hunt down the facts. So, when my brother texted “Way to go Jewish (I suppose) hammer thrower!” and I texted back, “Hadn’t thought of that” I quickly got on the case.
Ethan Katzberg certainly sounds like a Jewish name – and Katzberg himself looks like he could be Jewish – but it was hard to find anything to prove if he was. His father, who had first taught Ethan’s sister, and then Ethan, to throw the hammer at the Nanaimo Track and Field Club, is named Bernie. That sounds pretty Jewish too! His mother – Coralee – not so much.
I soon came across a Nanaimo News Bulletin story from 2013 about Mike Gogo’s Christmas Tree farm, which had been in his family for 84 years. Included is a picture of the Katzberg family, who had just picked out their tree! It was, apparently, their first time tree hunting … in Nanaimo, at least.
“A light came down from the sky and illuminated it from above,” joked Bernie. “And the kids helped pick it out too,” Coralee added, also stating that the family loves authentic trees. “The real ones are better,” Coralee said. “They smell good.”
Plenty of mixed marriage Jewish families out there who celebrate Christmas and Hanukkah. Was this a case of that? “My guess,” I texted my brothers and nephew “is his Dad is Jewish and his Mom is not.”
Clearly, we weren’t the only people wondering, as other queries started showing up online. There was a particularly long thread on Reddit … which would seem to show that Katzberg is NOT Jewish. As one comment noted:
Ethan and I went to the same high school (years apart). I was so proud of him today! The Jewish community is pretty small in Nanaimo and I haven’t seen his name mentioned anywhere, so I don’t think he’s Jewish.
Still, maybe a Jewish father and a non-Jewish mother? Plenty of other commenters thought that was possibile … but it doesn’t appear so according to these two comments from somebody else:
No he is not Jewish. I went to school with his father at a German Baptist college in Alberta.
Bernie’s family (of origin) attended Baptist church, so not Jewish. His ethnicity is German and he speaks (some) German. I went to school with him during our late teens.
But fear not, Jewish sports fans, there’s plenty more Jewish sports content in the rest of what I’m going to write. Admittedly (though I’m not much of a basketball fan) I was intending to write this in celebration of Canada’s first basketball medal since 1936. That drought continues, but still…
The common Jewish stereotype is that Jews are sports fans, but more likely to be team owners than athletes. But back in a time when Jews mostly lived in the inner city, sports were seen as a way to assimilate. Even a way to a better life. Back in the day, there were Jewish track stars, Jewish boxers, and Jewish basketball players too.
The 1936 Olympics had been awarded to Berlin in 1931, a few years before Adolph Hitler came to power. As the time drew closer, there were those who were pushing for the International Olympic Committee to move the Games somewhere else. Apparently, the most the IOC was willing to do was to push the Germans to include one token Jewish athlete on their Olympic team. Many Jewish athletes from around the world refused to go to Berlin and planned to attend The People’s Olympiad in Barcelona instead, but this leftist-inspired competition was called off shortly before it was to start due to the outbreak of the Spanish Civil War.
Still, a handful of Jewish athletes did attend the Berlin Olympics … including two members of Canada’s basketball team which won a silver medal at the first Games where basketball was a full medal sport.
It’s often said that Canada was represented in basketball at the 1936 Berlin Olympics by the Windsor Ford V8 team. That’s only mostly true. The Ford V8s were the 1935-36 Canadian Senior Basketball Champions, but for the Olympics they picked up four members of the runner-up Victoria Blue Ribbons. (Windsor, Ontario – said to be because of its proximity to the United States – and Victoria, British Columbia, were the hotbeds of Canadian basketball at this time.) The Windsor team included two Jewish players: Irving “Toots” Meretsky and Julius “Goldie” Goldman.
Though he had moved to Canada when he was two years old, Goldman had been born in Mayesville, South Carolina, to Lithuanian immigrant parents. Being American-born, he wasn’t allowed to play for Canada, so instead served as an assistant coach and the team’s representative on the 1936 Olympic Basketball Rules Committee. It was in that capacity that Goldman would modernize the game by suggesting the jump ball to restart play after every basket be eliminated … although this rule change would not be implemented until after the Berlin Olympics.
Irving Meretsky was born in Windsor in 1912 and lived his whole life there. When he died in 2006 at the age of 94, he was the last surviving member of the 1936 Olympic basketball team. A 2015 story by Tony Atherton of Postmedia News on the web site of Canada Basketball tells an anecdote Meretsky must have told many times in his life about seeing Adolph Hitler at the Opening Ceremonies:
Down on the field, among the ranks of athletes from 52 nations, a skinny 24-year-old in a red blazer and white ducks, a Maple Leaf upon his breast, couldn’t keep an impish smile from spreading across his face. “He looks like Charlie Chaplin!” Toots Meretsky told himself. And no doubt felt better for it.
Toots was a Jewish kid from Windsor, Ont., standing in the heart of Nazi Germany, staring up at Hitler – on Shabbat, no less. He had passed ranks of crimson, swastika-emblazoned banners on his way into the arena. Now, he was hemmed in by an honour battalion of the German army. Everywhere he looked there were brownshirts, blackshirts, and blond, ecstatic Hitler Youth. He knew of the systematic oppression of German Jews since the Nazis had come to power three years before. He knew about the boycotting of Jewish businesses, the revocation of citizenship, the edicts against intermarriage, not to mention the random vandalism, beatings, and intimidation.
But Adolf Hitler looked like Charlie Chaplin. So Toots had to smile.
Basketball was almost an afterthought at the Berlin Olympics. The Germans didn’t think fans would care to watch, so the games were played on a modified outdoor clay tennis court. Mainly because of the jump ball rule, the lack of a 24-second clock (which wouldn’t come to be until the 1950s) and the fact that goaltending wasn’t against the rules, basketball was much more lowing scoring in this era. En route to the gold medal game against the United States, Canada posted the following victories:
24–17 over Brazil
34–23 over Latvia
27–9 over Switzerland
41–21 over Uruguay
42–15 over Poland
The U.S. got a bye in the first round when Spain withdrew, and then won:
52–28 over Estonia
(Bye through the third round)
56–23 over Philippines
25–10 over Mexico
Rain would mar the championship game on August 14, 1936.
Years later, [Canadian] team member Gord Aitchison would describe the scene to the Windsor Star. “On the opening play, an American player raced down the court, caught a pass as his feet went from under him and completed the last 15 or 20 feet to the basket sliding on the seat of his shorts, water spraying out from both sides.” The rest of the game followed suit.
Sam Balter, a U.S. point guard (and the only Jewish-American medal winner in 1936) regretted the circumstances of that game for the rest of his life, he told Sports Illustrated. “A comedy of errors and unfortunate circumstances had combined to make a sandlot affair of what should have been the greatest basketball tournament ever,” he said.
The jump ball rule meant the height advantage of the American team would have been big at any rate, but on a soggy court where dribbling was impossible and even passing the ball was difficult, it proved a huge advantage. The U.S. led 15–4 at halftime, and while the Canadians played them even in the second half the final score was 19–8.
Unfortunately, the Olympic Committee had only minted seven medals of each color for the basketball competition. The Canadians drew lots to determine which of their players would receive a silver medal. Toots Meretsky didn’t win … however, after a media stir about the oversight, the IOC minted a new silver medal for Toots in 1999 from the original mold.
“Our group of guys were the greatest in the world,” Toots told a sports website sometime before his death in 2006 broke the last direct link with Canada’s only Olympic medal winning basketball team. “We all helped one another, we worked together, we played together.”
Another fascinating story. No doubt you have researched the Rudi Ball and Gustav Jaenecke story and the German hockey team and the 1936 Winter Olympics. Ball was notably one of the only German Jewish athletes at the Games.
Can’t say I’ve really researched it. I know about both of them, but not much more than that…
I found this very interesting! I recall, as a child, a Jewish boy, a few year old than I was, won a race at my public school. It was a field day at my school, but included several other schools in the area in downtown Toronto. I think one could have counted the number of Jews watching on two hands, but he won, the dash, and the crowd went wild. Now this was during WW ll and at that time, many Canadians were unaware of the horrors that had befallen the Jews of Europe. (The Yiddish paper, Forward, printing the news, in Yiddish, but there was little or nothing in the Toronto Telegram, or the Toronto Star or the Globe and Mail.) When he received his winning ribbon, he was applauded with enthusiatic glee by all, including those who were supporting their own schools. The reason he was lauded, he wore very thick eyeglasses, and everyone thought that he was a “geek”. He was teased constantly because of this. That was the “prejudice” at that time. The fact that he was Jewish was not important. Times have changed. By the way, I wish could remember his name. I do remember that after the war, his family’s business improved and he moved to that newly developed area called “Forest Hill”, and I don’t know what happened after that!
P.S. We got all three papers, as my brothers would deliver them, and part of their wages was copies for the family. In my Social Studies classes, we were asked to make “scrapebooks” of items about the war. Dad got the Forward, and when I cut out articles about the Jews in Europe, and with Dad’s help, wrote the translations in English, one teacher couldn’t believe it. I still remember how she questioned me about the translations telling me that they were exaggerations. When the war ended, she was very apologetic!! When the photographs of the camps were published , (thanks to General Eisenhower), they went into my collection, and this particular teacher cried, and hugged me. That is something I will never forget. Miss Penner was an amazing teacher, and I think she was my inspiration to go into that profession. The fact that she accepted that she was wrong, told me that teachers are human beings.
You sure know so much!!! Very impressive!
It’s more like “know how to find stuff” … but thank you!
This splendidly researched story comes at a time that Jews are being challenged all over the world and especially in The Jewish State. As a native of Brooklyn, the worst sports story to come out of Hitler’s Olympics was the decision by the U.S. Olympic Committee to ban Brooklyn-born track star Marty Glickman from competing.Marty, who turned out to be one of greatest multi-sport broadcasters in N.Y. history, never forgave the Committee for keeping him from competing.
Interestingly, with all the challenges, Israeli athletes enjoyed the best Olympics in the little country’s history. Marty Glickman would have been proud. I am!
I just read something interesting about Marty Glickman. (There’s a new book out about him.) Would have liked to include him in the story… but I was already a little too all over the place. So, this is good!
Interesting stories! Excellent research.
Really enjoyed this piece of history and especially the connection to the Jews. Thanks for writing Eric, whatever you write it’s always interesting.
My parents knew Bobby Rosenfeld. She was a top Canadian star. Were she from the USA a movie would have been made of her life staring Meryl Streep.
But there are stars in all areas of Iife. Good and Bad.