One hundred and one years ago yesterday, on April 5, 1919, Joe Hall passed away at the Columbus Sanitarium in Seattle, Washington. Hall died of pneumonia, as did so many victims of the Spanish Flu epidemic around the world between 1918 and 1920. (Sources used to put the death toll around 20 million worldwide, but more recent estimates have moved that number to more like 100 million.)
Last year on April 5, I visited Joe Hall’s gravesite in Vancouver on the 100th anniversary of his death. Hall’s illness, along with several other of his Montreal Canadiens teammates, is the reason that the deciding game of the 1919 Stanley Cup Final was never played. The fact that Hall died just four days after the series was cancelled makes him the most famous hockey victim of the Spanish Flu … but he wasn’t the only one.
George Kennedy owned and operated the Montreal Canadiens from 1910 until his death on October 19, 1921. Kennedy also contracted the Spanish Flu while the team was in Seattle for the Stanley Cup in 1919. Although he lived for another 2 1/2 years, it was said that Kennedy never really recovered.
Three years before George Kennedy died, Hamby Shore of the Ottawa Senators had been the first member of the hockey community to fall to the Spanish Flu. Shore caught the disease while nursing his wife, who made a complete recovery. Sadly, he died on October 13, 1918.
On the day of Hamby Shore’s funeral in Ottawa on October 16, 1918, the hockey world suffered another loss when the son of Jack Marshall (who had starred at the game’s highest level from 1900 to 1917) died of the flu. Bob Marshall was just 12 years old.
Having been called on a few times of late to share my knowledge of the Spanish Flu and the 1919 Stanley Cup, I was asked recently if I knew how many hockey players had been sick during the epidemic. I spent an hour or two last week trying to put together a list. This may not be a complete compilation, but it’s certainly a start. Everyone listed here seems to have made a complete recovery. (Most of the pictures accompanying the newspaper stories are courtesy of the Society for International Hockey Research.)
I decided to limit myself to professional hockey players, but I did come across a few other big names from other sports. Babe Ruth’s case was said to be a mild one, but imagine how different the history of baseball would be if Ruth had died in the fall of 1918!
Jim Jeffries was the heavyweight boxing champion of the world from 1899 to 1904, and famously came out of retirement in 1910 to fight Jack Johnson as the “Great White Hope.” Jeffries recovered from the Spanish Flu, as his doctors believed he would.
Former Canadian heavyweight champ Tommy Burns (who lost the title to Jack Johnson in 1908) also came down with the flu in 1918 while in training with the army in Vancouver. Though his case sounds bad, it was soon reported that Burns was improving.
As for other hockey players, while Hamby Shore was dying in the fall of 1918, his Ottawa teammate Eddie Gerard was recovering from his own bout of Spanish Flu.
And at least two club executives in Ottawa were reported to be down with the flu as well. Still, the NHL meeting went on as scheduled on October 19 … although only three delegates were in attendance.
Frank Foyston of the Seattle Metropolitans was also sick in October of 1918. He was training with the Royal Air Force in Toronto during World War I at the time. Toronto newspapers mention that he was sick, some articles noting he had the Spanish Flu, which was confirmed by his former teammate Norm Fowler in a letter to Pacific Coast Hockey Association President Frank Patrick in Vancouver. (The War ended before Foyston was ever sent overseas.)
Fowler, who was in the army and training in Victoria, British Columbia, late in 1918 before serving in the Canadian Siberian Expeditionary Force to bolster the Allied presence during the Russian Revolution, would also become a sufferer of the Spanish Flu. Fowler recovered, and after missing the 1918–19 season due to his military service, he signed on with the Victoria Aristocrats hockey team in 1919–20.
The British Columbia capital seemed to be a particularly difficult place for hockey players during the Spanish Flu epidemic. Dubbie Kerr, who hadn’t played hockey at all in 1917–18 and would play just one game for Victoria during the 1918–19 season was reported sick with Spanish Flu in the fall of 1918.
Aristocrats captain Eddie Oatman came down with a case in late December of 1918 and missed the team’s first game of the PCHA season before returning to action in January.
After Oatman recovered, team owner, coach and star player Lester Patrick came down with the disease.
Though it’s said that Lester was extremely diligent in insisting that other players be sent home if they experienced any symptoms, Moose Johnson, Clem Loughlin, Bob Genge and Alf Barbour of the Aristocrats all got sick too. Every Victoria player recovered.
Given that many sporting events were cancelled in Victoria in the fall of 1918 (as they were all across North America, where – like today – meetings, schools, theaters and the like had all been shut down) it’s amazing to me that the PCHA never closed the rinks during the 1918–19 season. Of course, the league only had three teams, as did the NHL, but whereas the Spanish Flu epidemic was considered essentially over in November on the East Coast – well before the the NHL season began in late December — life didn’t really get back to normal on the West Coast until January. And, of course the disease would flare up again later.
It’s long been said that the Montreal players who got sick at the end of March during the 1919 Stanley Cup Final contracted the disease while in Victoria. I don’t believe that to be true. (In my research, the team was never in Victoria en route from Montreal to Seattle.) I think it was just an easy story for lazy writers who knew that so many Victoria hockey players had been sick. I also doubt they picked up the virus in Vancouver, which is another theory. The Canadiens were in Vancouver for barely 24 hours nearly two weeks before anyone got sick, and unlike COVID-19, the Spanish flu presented symptoms almost immediately.
Although there were no deaths associated with the flu in Seattle during March of 1919, I think the Canadiens contracted the disease while they were there. In addition to Joe Hall and George Kennedy, Canadiens who got sick in Seattle include Jack McDonald, Newsy Lalonde, Billy Coutu, Louis Berlinguette, and Odie Cleghorn. Roy Rickey, Muzz Murray and manager Pete Muldoon of the Seattle Metropolitans were also stricken with influenza. All would recover fairly quickly.
For more on this topic, you can see the story I wrote here in March of 2017, or search out several interesting stories by others writers about Joe Hall, Hamby Shore, and the 1919 Stanley Cup that have been written since the start of the COVID 19 pandemic.
LATE ADDITION (October 5, 2020): While researching my upcoming book on the Kenora Thistles (due out in the fall of 2021), I discovered that Si Griffis was also stricken with the Spanish Flu. The former Thistles star had announced his retirement from the Vancouver Millionaires late in the 1917-18 season, but despite coming down with the flu in January or February of 1919, returned to the Millionaires in March.
And one more. Harry Mummery was reported as having the flu in Toronto’s Globe newspaper on December 16, 1918. I’d say that’s a decent reason why he missed the first five games of the 1918-19 season and didn’t play his first until January 9.
19 thoughts on “Hockey in the Time of the Spanish Flu”
Good morning Eric,
Another fascinating posting. Thanks for sharing.
Keep working and keep well….
I read Fever Season and it was so sad when Joe Hall died. I also remember when you were in Vancouver last year and went to see his grave and sent me the pictures that you have posted in this article. I had no idea how many other hockey players were affected with the flu but it was uplifting to read how many recovered. I hope we will read of many people who have Covid 19 now, who also are recovering or have already recovered.
Very interesting. Great research!
Wow Eric .
This is a very healthy bit of research, nicely laid out in a meaningful way by attaching it to the 1918 flu.
Well done. Hope you and the family are all healthy and hanging in there.
Hi Eric! Thanks again for another interesting article. I particularly liked reading about all who recovered from the flu. May those affected with our ongoing pandemic have successful results. Stay well.
Well done, Eric. You have earned an MHR from the world of hockey — Master Hockey Researcher
You may have done better research on other subjects but this is as good as it gets — and then some!
Hi Eric, It’s reassuring that the NHL and other sports organizations seem to pay attention to history. With the help of modern media they are responding to coronavirus more effectively. Hopefully we won’t lose as many players this time. Thank you for the retrospect.
Fascinating piece of work. I recall an elderly gentleman offering me this rhyme from his childhood: I had a little bird, it’s name was Enza, I opened the window and in-flew-Enza.
I recently re-watched the PBS American Experience documentary about the Spanish Flu. (I believe it was from 1998.) There were a lot of elderly people (and the talking heads) who mentioned that rhyme.
Excellent story. Thanks for sharing!
Very well done. Congrats. And I received an email earlier in the day calling my attention to it from another of your email subscribers, Scotty Bowman, so he liked it too. Hope you’re well and staying safe.
Amazing research Eric. Very interesting to hear about Babe Ruth. Baseball history would have gone in a completely different direction had he died. Makes you think. Stay safe.
Many thanks Eric for this post… I know virtually nothing about Spanish Flu. And to learn how it affected hockey players & other athletes over 100 years ago is very interesting.
You always bring hockey/sports history alive for me!
Chag Sameah my friend, Sherri-Ellen T-D.
You are amazing. Thanks for the ‘then and now’ perspective.
Eric – this is really so well done … the inclusion of the newspaper clippings and the images gives this article so much currency. Joe Hall’s death date and my birthday are the same date, so although I knew he died of the flu, I will now remember all the particulars for sure. The Martin Rosenthal references in the October 19 NHL meeting are also of interest as I plan to try and learn a bit more about Rosenthal. His mother and father were prominent in Ottawa’s Jewish Community and his brother was a long time alderman in our city.
I have just found out that Robert Genge was my husband’s great grandfather. He passed away when his daughter, Mavis, was 5. We don’t know anything about him except what’s on Wikipedia. Do you have any information about him?